The decision to pursue a medical malpractice lawsuit is rarely easy. You’ve suffered harm at the hands of healthcare providers you trusted, and now you’re contemplating a legal battle against well-funded hospitals and insurance companies. Understanding what lies ahead can help you prepare mentally, emotionally, and practically for the journey.
If you’re considering a medical malpractice claim in New Jersey, this comprehensive guide will walk you through each stage of the process—from initial consultation to resolution—so you know exactly what to expect.
Before You File: The Investigation Phase
A medical malpractice lawsuit doesn’t begin with filing papers at the courthouse. It starts with a thorough investigation to determine whether you have a viable claim.
Initial Consultation with an Attorney
Your first step is meeting with an experienced medical malpractice attorney. During this consultation, you’ll discuss:
- The medical care you received and what went wrong
- Your injuries and how they’ve affected your life
- The healthcare providers and facilities involved
- Any documentation you’ve gathered (medical records, bills, photos)
Most reputable malpractice attorneys offer free initial consultations and work on contingency fees, meaning you pay nothing upfront and only pay if you recover compensation.
Medical Records Review
Your attorney will obtain complete copies of your medical records from all relevant providers. In New Jersey, you have a legal right to your medical records, and healthcare providers must provide them within 30 days of request.
These records are the foundation of your case. They document:
- Your condition before treatment
- The care provided (or not provided)
- Communications between healthcare providers
- The outcome and your injuries
Expert Medical Evaluation
Medical malpractice cases require expert opinions to establish that the standard of care was breached. Your attorney will have your records reviewed by qualified medical experts in the relevant specialty.
These experts will assess:
- Whether the healthcare providers met the applicable standard of care
- How the care deviated from acceptable practice
- Whether the breach caused your injuries
- The extent and permanence of your harm
This evaluation determines whether your case has merit. If experts conclude that malpractice occurred, your attorney will proceed. If not, a reputable attorney will tell you honestly rather than pursue a case unlikely to succeed.
Filing the Lawsuit
Once investigation confirms a viable claim, your attorney will prepare and file the formal lawsuit.
The Complaint
The complaint is the document that officially starts your lawsuit. It includes:
- Identification of all defendants (doctors, hospitals, nurses, other providers)
- A description of what happened and how the defendants were negligent
- The injuries you suffered as a result
- The compensation you’re seeking
In New Jersey, medical malpractice cases are filed in Superior Court, typically in the county where the malpractice occurred or where a defendant is located.
Service of Process
After filing, defendants must be formally notified of the lawsuit through “service of process.” Each defendant receives a copy of the complaint and a summons requiring them to respond.
Defendants typically have 35 days to file an answer to the complaint, either denying the allegations or raising defenses.
The Affidavit of Merit
New Jersey law requires a critical additional step in medical malpractice cases: the Affidavit of Merit. Within 60 days of each defendant’s answer, you must provide an affidavit from a qualified medical expert stating:
- The expert is licensed in the same specialty as the defendant (or a related specialty)
- The expert has reviewed the relevant medical records
- There is a reasonable probability that the defendant’s care fell below professional standards
This requirement exists to filter out frivolous claims. Failure to provide a timely Affidavit of Merit can result in dismissal of your case.
Your attorney will have identified appropriate experts during the investigation phase and will ensure this deadline is met.
The Discovery Phase
After initial pleadings are filed, the case enters discovery—an extended period where both sides gather information and evidence. Discovery in medical malpractice cases typically takes 12 to 24 months.
Written Discovery
Interrogatories: Written questions that must be answered under oath. Defendants will ask about your medical history, the treatment at issue, your injuries, and your damages. You’ll also send interrogatories to defendants about their training, procedures, and the care they provided.
Requests for Production: Demands for documents and records relevant to the case. Both sides exchange medical records, policies and procedures, communications, expert reports, and other evidence.
Requests for Admissions: Requests that the other side admit certain facts, which can streamline trial by eliminating disputed issues.
Depositions
Depositions are in-person, sworn testimony taken outside of court but recorded by a court reporter. They’re often the most significant part of discovery.
Your Deposition: Defense attorneys will ask detailed questions about your medical history, the treatment you received, how you were injured, and how your injuries have affected your life. This can last several hours or even multiple days. Your attorney will prepare you thoroughly beforehand.
Defendant Depositions: Your attorney will depose the doctors, nurses, and other providers involved in your care. These depositions often reveal crucial information about what happened and why.
Expert Depositions: Both sides depose the other’s expert witnesses to understand their opinions and test their credibility.
Independent Medical Examinations
Defendants will typically request that you be examined by a doctor of their choosing—an “independent medical examination” or IME. Despite the name, these examiners are hired by the defense and often minimize injuries.
You generally must attend the IME, but your attorney can provide guidance on what to expect and may attend or have the examination recorded.
Settlement Negotiations
Many medical malpractice cases settle before trial. Settlement can occur at any point in the process, but serious negotiations often happen after discovery is complete and both sides understand the strengths and weaknesses of the case.
Mediation
New Jersey courts often require or encourage mediation—a settlement conference with a neutral mediator who helps the parties find common ground. Mediation is non-binding; if you don’t reach agreement, you proceed toward trial.
Benefits of mediation:
- Opportunity to resolve the case without trial risk
- Private and confidential process
- You maintain control over the outcome
Evaluating Settlement Offers
Your attorney will help you evaluate any settlement offers, considering:
- The strength of your evidence
- The range of likely jury verdicts
- The risks of going to trial
- Your immediate and long-term needs
- How long a trial would take
The decision to accept or reject a settlement is always yours. A good attorney will provide honest advice but respect your wishes.
Pre-Trial Motions and Preparation
If the case doesn’t settle, it moves toward trial. In the months before trial, both sides file motions and prepare their presentations.
Motions in Limine
These motions ask the judge to rule on evidentiary issues before trial begins—for example, whether certain evidence can be presented to the jury or whether expert testimony meets legal standards.
Jury Selection
In New Jersey, medical malpractice cases are tried before juries unless both sides agree to a bench trial (judge only). Jury selection (voir dire) involves questioning potential jurors to identify bias and select a fair panel.
Medical malpractice jury selection is particularly important because jurors often have preconceptions about lawsuits, doctors, and healthcare.
Trial Preparation
Your attorney will prepare you to testify, organize exhibits, coordinate expert witnesses, and develop opening statements and closing arguments. This is intensive work that experienced trial attorneys take very seriously.
The Trial
Medical malpractice trials in New Jersey typically last one to three weeks, depending on complexity.
Opening Statements
Both sides present opening statements outlining what the evidence will show. These are not arguments—they’re roadmaps for the jury.
Plaintiff’s Case
As the plaintiff, your side presents evidence first. This includes:
Your Testimony: You’ll describe your treatment, injuries, and how your life has been affected. Defense attorneys will cross-examine you.
Expert Testimony: Your medical experts will explain the standard of care, how it was breached, and how that breach caused your injuries. Expert testimony is often the most critical part of a malpractice trial.
Other Witnesses: Family members, friends, and others may testify about your injuries and their impact on your life.
Documentary Evidence: Medical records, bills, photographs, and other documents are presented to the jury.
Defendant’s Case
After you rest, defendants present their case, including their own experts who will dispute liability, causation, or damages. Your attorney will cross-examine their witnesses.
Closing Arguments
Both sides summarize the evidence and argue why the jury should rule in their favor.
Jury Deliberation and Verdict
The jury deliberates in private and returns a verdict. In New Jersey, civil jury verdicts don’t require unanimity—five of six jurors must agree.
If the jury finds in your favor, they’ll award damages. If they find for the defendant, you receive nothing (though appeals may be possible).
Post-Trial: What Happens After the Verdict
A verdict isn’t always the final word.
Post-Trial Motions
The losing side may file motions asking the judge to overturn the verdict, reduce damages, or order a new trial. These motions are rarely granted but can delay final resolution.
Appeals
Either side can appeal the verdict to New Jersey’s Appellate Division. Appeals focus on legal errors during trial, not whether the jury reached the right decision. Appeals can add one to two years to the timeline.
Collection
If you win and appeals are exhausted, the defendant must pay the judgment. Medical malpractice defendants typically have insurance that covers judgments, so collection is usually straightforward.
The Timeline: How Long Does This Take?
Medical malpractice cases are not quick. From investigation through resolution:
- Investigation: 2-6 months
- Filing and pleadings: 2-4 months
- Discovery: 12-24 months
- Settlement negotiations/mediation: Ongoing throughout
- Trial: 1-3 weeks
- Post-trial/appeals: 1-2 years (if applicable)
Total timeline: Most cases resolve within 2-4 years. Cases that go to trial and appeal can take longer.
The Emotional Reality
Beyond the legal process, medical malpractice litigation is emotionally demanding. You’ll be asked to relive painful experiences repeatedly. Defense attorneys will challenge your credibility and minimize your injuries. The process is long and uncertain.
Having an attorney who understands this emotional dimension makes a significant difference. Your lawyer should keep you informed, prepare you for difficult moments, and advocate fiercely on your behalf so you can focus on healing.
Why Legal Representation Matters
Medical malpractice litigation is complex, expensive, and adversarial. Hospitals and insurers have teams of experienced lawyers and substantial resources. Going it alone is not a realistic option.
An experienced medical malpractice attorney provides:
- Expert evaluation of your claim’s merits
- Access to qualified medical experts
- Resources to fund expensive litigation
- Strategic guidance throughout the process
- Skilled negotiation and trial advocacy
Most importantly, your attorney levels the playing field against well-funded defendants who would otherwise have every advantage.
—
Contact Gencarelli & Rimmassa Law Firm
If you’ve been harmed by medical malpractice in New Jersey and are considering legal action, the experienced attorneys at Gencarelli & Rimmassa Law Firm can guide you through every step of the process. We’ve successfully represented clients throughout New Jersey in complex medical malpractice cases, and we understand both the legal and emotional challenges you’re facing.
We work on a contingency fee basis—you pay nothing unless we recover compensation for you. Our team has the resources, expert network, and trial experience to take on hospitals, doctors, and insurance companies.
Don’t face this process alone. Contact Gencarelli & Rimmassa today for a free, confidential consultation to learn whether you have a viable claim and what to expect going forward.
Call (201) 549-8737 today for your free case evaluation. We’ll be with you every step of the way.
