Anesthesia is one of the most remarkable advances in modern medicine. It allows surgeons to perform life-saving procedures while patients remain unconscious, pain-free, and unaware. But anesthesia is also one of the most dangerous aspects of any surgical procedure—a delicate balance between keeping patients safely unconscious and preventing life-threatening complications.
When anesthesia errors occur, the consequences can be catastrophic: brain damage, permanent disability, and death. If you or a loved one has been harmed by an anesthesia error in New Jersey, understanding your rights is the first step toward seeking justice and compensation.
This comprehensive guide explains how anesthesia works, what can go wrong, who may be held liable, and how New Jersey law protects victims of anesthesia malpractice.
Understanding Anesthesia
Anesthesia involves using drugs to block pain, induce unconsciousness, or both. Different types of anesthesia are used depending on the procedure and patient needs.
Types of Anesthesia
General Anesthesia: The patient is rendered completely unconscious and unable to feel pain. This is used for major surgeries and requires careful monitoring of vital signs, breathing, and other functions.
Regional Anesthesia: Specific areas of the body are numbed while the patient remains conscious. Types include:
- Spinal anesthesia (injection into the spinal canal)
- Epidural anesthesia (commonly used during childbirth)
- Nerve blocks (numbing specific nerves)
Local Anesthesia: A small area is numbed for minor procedures. The patient remains fully conscious.
Sedation: Medications that relax the patient and reduce awareness, ranging from light sedation (patient is drowsy but responsive) to deep sedation (patient is nearly unconscious).
The Complexity of Anesthesia Administration
Administering anesthesia safely requires:
- Thorough pre-operative evaluation of the patient
- Selection of appropriate anesthetic agents and doses
- Continuous monitoring throughout the procedure
- Immediate response to any complications
- Proper management of emergence from anesthesia
- Post-operative monitoring and pain management
Each of these steps presents opportunities for error.
Common Types of Anesthesia Errors
Anesthesia errors can occur before, during, or after surgical procedures.
Pre-Operative Errors
Inadequate Patient Evaluation: Anesthesiologists must review the patient’s medical history, current medications, allergies, and previous anesthesia experiences. Failure to identify risk factors can lead to serious complications.
Failure to Identify Difficult Airway: Some patients have anatomical features that make intubation difficult. Failing to anticipate and plan for these challenges can result in airway emergencies.
Improper Fasting Instructions: Patients must avoid eating and drinking before general anesthesia to prevent aspiration (inhaling stomach contents into the lungs). Inadequate fasting can cause aspiration pneumonia, which can be fatal.
Failure to Review Medication Interactions: Some medications interact dangerously with anesthetic agents. Failing to identify and address these interactions can cause complications.
Dosing Errors
Overdose: Too much anesthesia can cause:
- Cardiovascular collapse
- Respiratory depression
- Prolonged unconsciousness
- Brain damage from oxygen deprivation
- Death
Underdose: Too little anesthesia can result in:
- Anesthesia awareness (patient wakes during surgery)
- Inadequate pain control
- Patient movement during critical surgical moments
Wrong Medication: Administering the wrong anesthetic agent due to labeling errors, similar-looking vials, or confusion.
Monitoring Failures
Throughout surgery, the anesthesiologist or nurse anesthetist must continuously monitor:
- Heart rate and rhythm
- Blood pressure
- Oxygen saturation
- Carbon dioxide levels
- Body temperature
- Depth of anesthesia
Failure to Recognize Complications: Signs of patient distress must be recognized immediately. Delayed response to dropping oxygen levels, abnormal heart rhythms, or other warning signs can cause permanent injury.
Equipment Failures: Monitoring equipment must be properly maintained and calibrated. Malfunctioning pulse oximeters, blood pressure cuffs, or other devices can mask developing problems.
Distraction: Anesthesiologists who are distracted—by conversations, phones, or other cases—may miss critical changes in patient status.
Airway Management Errors
Failed Intubation: Inserting the breathing tube into the esophagus instead of the trachea, or failing to secure the airway at all, can quickly lead to oxygen deprivation and brain damage.
Extubation Injuries: Removing the breathing tube too early, before the patient can breathe independently, can cause respiratory failure.
Dental and Soft Tissue Damage: Rough intubation technique can damage teeth, lips, tongue, or the throat.
Regional Anesthesia Errors
Improper Needle Placement: Spinal and epidural injections require precise needle positioning. Errors can cause:
- Nerve damage
- Paralysis
- Severe headaches
- Infection
- Bleeding
Wrong Medication or Dose: Injecting the wrong substance or incorrect amount into the spinal or epidural space can cause permanent neurological damage.
Failure to Recognize Complications: High spinal blocks or epidural hematomas require immediate intervention. Delayed recognition can result in permanent paralysis.
Post-Operative Errors
Premature Discharge from Recovery: Patients must be adequately recovered before leaving the post-anesthesia care unit. Premature discharge can lead to respiratory problems or falls.
Inadequate Monitoring: Complications like respiratory depression from residual anesthesia can occur hours after surgery. Inadequate monitoring can allow these problems to become life-threatening.
Failure to Manage Pain: While not always malpractice, inadequate post-operative pain management can cause unnecessary suffering and complications.
Devastating Consequences of Anesthesia Errors
Anesthesia errors can cause some of the most catastrophic injuries in medicine.
Brain Damage
The brain requires constant oxygen supply. When anesthesia errors cause oxygen deprivation—whether from overdose, airway problems, or cardiovascular collapse—brain damage can occur within minutes. Effects range from mild cognitive impairment to persistent vegetative state.
Death
Anesthesia-related deaths, while rare, do occur. They may result from:
- Cardiac arrest during surgery
- Respiratory failure
- Severe allergic reactions (anaphylaxis)
- Malignant hyperthermia (a rare genetic reaction to certain anesthetics)
- Aspiration of stomach contents
Anesthesia Awareness
One of the most psychologically traumatic anesthesia complications is waking up during surgery while paralyzed. Patients who experience anesthesia awareness may:
- Feel pain during the procedure
- Hear conversations in the operating room
- Be unable to move or communicate their distress
- Develop post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD)
While relatively rare, anesthesia awareness affects thousands of patients each year and can cause lasting psychological harm.
Nerve Damage and Paralysis
Regional anesthesia errors can damage nerves or the spinal cord, causing:
- Permanent numbness or pain
- Weakness or paralysis of limbs
- Bowel or bladder dysfunction
- Sexual dysfunction
Other Complications
- Stroke from blood pressure fluctuations
- Heart attack triggered by cardiovascular stress
- Aspiration pneumonia
- Severe allergic reactions
- Prolonged recovery and hospitalization
Who Can Be Held Liable for Anesthesia Errors?
Anesthesia errors may involve multiple responsible parties.
Anesthesiologists
Physician anesthesiologists are medical doctors with specialized training in anesthesia. They bear primary responsibility for:
- Pre-operative evaluation and planning
- Selection of anesthetic agents and techniques
- Supervision of the anesthesia team
- Managing complications
Certified Registered Nurse Anesthetists (CRNAs)
CRNAs are advanced practice nurses who administer anesthesia, often under physician supervision. Depending on the circumstances, CRNAs may be independently liable for their negligence or may create liability for their supervising physician.
Surgeons
While not primarily responsible for anesthesia, surgeons may share liability if they:
- Failed to communicate important patient information
- Proceeded with surgery despite anesthesia concerns
- Failed to respond appropriately to anesthesia emergencies
Hospitals and Surgery Centers
Healthcare facilities may be liable for:
- Inadequate anesthesia staffing
- Failure to maintain monitoring equipment
- Poor policies and procedures
- Negligent credentialing of anesthesia providers
- Inadequate post-operative monitoring
Under respondeat superior, facilities may also be liable for the negligence of employee anesthesia providers.
Proving Anesthesia Malpractice in New Jersey
Like all medical malpractice claims, anesthesia cases require proof of four elements.
Duty of Care
Once an anesthesiologist or CRNA accepts responsibility for your anesthesia care, they owe you a duty to provide care meeting professional standards.
Breach of Standard of Care
Expert testimony must establish what a reasonably competent anesthesia provider would have done and how the defendant’s conduct fell short. This might involve showing:
- Proper monitoring protocols were not followed
- Dosage calculations were incorrect
- Signs of complications were ignored
- Airway management was inadequate
Causation
You must prove that the breach caused your injury. Anesthesia cases often involve complex causation questions because patients undergoing surgery may have multiple risk factors.
Damages
You must demonstrate actual harm—physical injuries, medical expenses, lost income, pain and suffering, or wrongful death.
New Jersey’s Affidavit of Merit
Within 60 days of the defendant’s answer, you must file an Affidavit of Merit from a qualified expert confirming that malpractice likely occurred. Given the specialized nature of anesthesia, this expert should typically be a board-certified anesthesiologist.
The Investigation Process
Anesthesia malpractice cases require careful investigation and expert analysis.
Key Evidence
- Anesthesia records: Detailed documentation of all drugs administered, vital signs, and events during surgery
- Pre-operative evaluation: Assessment of patient risk factors and planning
- Operative notes: Surgeon’s account of the procedure
- Nursing notes: Observations from operating room and recovery nurses
- Monitoring data: Electronic records from monitoring equipment
- Post-operative records: Documentation of recovery and any complications
- Expert analysis: Review by qualified anesthesiologists who can identify deviations from standard care
Challenges in Anesthesia Cases
These cases present unique challenges:
- Records are technical and require expert interpretation
- Complications can have multiple possible causes
- The medical community may be reluctant to criticize colleagues
- Defense experts will often dispute causation
Experienced legal representation with access to qualified experts is essential.
Statute of Limitations
New Jersey’s two-year statute of limitations applies to anesthesia malpractice claims. However, determining when the clock starts can be complex:
- Some injuries are immediately apparent
- Others may not manifest until later
- The discovery rule may extend the deadline if you couldn’t reasonably have known about the malpractice
Consulting an attorney promptly is important to protect your rights.
Seeking Justice After Anesthesia Malpractice
Anesthesia errors can change lives in an instant. Patients who entered the hospital expecting routine surgery may emerge with permanent brain damage, paralysis, or other devastating injuries. Families may lose loved ones who should have survived.
While no lawsuit can undo this harm, pursuing a malpractice claim serves important purposes:
- Obtaining compensation for medical care, lost income, and suffering
- Holding negligent providers accountable
- Encouraging safety improvements that protect future patients
- Providing answers about what went wrong
If you believe anesthesia malpractice has harmed you or your loved one, you deserve to understand your options.
—
Contact Gencarelli & Rimmassa Law Firm
If you or a loved one has suffered harm from an anesthesia error in New Jersey, Gencarelli & Rimmassa Law Firm is here to help. We understand the devastating impact of anesthesia injuries and have the experience and resources to pursue these complex cases.
Our team works with leading anesthesiology experts to investigate what happened, determine whether malpractice occurred, and build compelling cases for our clients. We take on hospitals, surgery centers, and insurance companies to fight for the compensation our clients deserve.
We work on contingency—you pay nothing unless we win your case.
New Jersey law limits the time you have to file a claim. Don’t wait to get the answers you need.
Call (201) 549-8737 today for your free, confidential consultation. We’re ready to fight for you.
