Finding the right attorney can make or break your medical malpractice case. These cases are among the most complex, expensive, and hard-fought in civil litigation. The attorney you choose will determine not just your likelihood of success, but also your experience throughout what can be a long and challenging process.
If you’re searching for a medical malpractice lawyer in New Jersey, this guide will help you understand what qualities to prioritize, what questions to ask, and how to recognize an attorney who can truly advocate for your interests.
Why Your Choice of Attorney Matters So Much
Medical malpractice cases are different from other personal injury claims. They involve:
Medical Complexity: Understanding what went wrong requires deep knowledge of medical procedures, standards of care, and scientific evidence.
Expensive Litigation: These cases require substantial upfront investment in medical experts, records review, depositions, and trial preparation—often $50,000 to $100,000 or more before trial.
Aggressive Defense: Hospitals and doctors are defended by well-funded insurance companies with experienced legal teams who vigorously contest every claim.
Specialized Procedures: New Jersey’s Affidavit of Merit requirement, expert witness rules, and other procedural requirements demand specialized knowledge.
An attorney who occasionally handles malpractice cases among a general practice simply cannot match the skill, resources, and experience of a dedicated malpractice attorney.
Key Qualities to Look For
1. Dedicated Medical Malpractice Experience
The most important factor is whether the attorney focuses specifically on medical malpractice. Ask:
How much of your practice is devoted to medical malpractice?
Ideally, you want an attorney or firm where medical malpractice represents a substantial majority of their caseload—70% or more. Attorneys who occasionally handle malpractice cases won’t have the depth of experience needed.
How many medical malpractice cases have you handled?
Look for attorneys who have handled dozens or hundreds of cases over many years, not just a handful.
What types of medical malpractice cases have you handled?
Experience with cases similar to yours matters. An attorney who has handled multiple birth injury cases will understand the specific medical issues and expert needs better than one who has never handled that type of case.
2. Trial Experience
Many attorneys settle cases without ever trying one. While settlement can be appropriate, you need an attorney who is willing and able to take your case to trial if necessary.
How many medical malpractice cases have you tried to verdict?
Look for attorneys who have tried multiple cases to jury verdict. Insurance companies know which attorneys will actually go to trial—and they offer better settlements to those who will.
What were the outcomes of those trials?
While no attorney wins every case, a track record of favorable verdicts demonstrates courtroom competence. Don’t be afraid to ask about specific results.
When was your last medical malpractice trial?
Recent trial experience matters. An attorney who hasn’t tried a case in five years may have lost their edge.
3. Resources to Handle Complex Cases
Medical malpractice cases are expensive to pursue properly. Your attorney must have the financial resources to:
- Obtain and review extensive medical records
- Hire top-tier medical experts (who may charge $500-$1,000+ per hour)
- Take numerous depositions
- Retain economists, life care planners, and other specialized experts
- Fund trial preparation and presentation
Does the firm have the resources to fund my case through trial if necessary?
A firm that cannot afford to take cases to trial will feel pressure to accept inadequate settlements.
Will my case receive adequate attention, or will it be one of hundreds?
Some high-volume firms take on more cases than they can properly handle. You want an attorney with a manageable caseload who can give your case the attention it deserves.
4. A Strong Network of Medical Experts
Expert testimony is essential in medical malpractice cases. Your attorney needs relationships with qualified medical experts who can:
- Review records and identify breaches in the standard of care
- Provide Affidavits of Merit within New Jersey’s 60-day deadline
- Testify persuasively at deposition and trial
How do you identify and work with medical experts?
Experienced malpractice attorneys have cultivated relationships with experts across medical specialties over years of practice. They know which experts are credible, articulate, and effective.
Do you have experts available in the specialty relevant to my case?
If your case involves cardiology, you need a cardiology expert. If it involves obstetrics, you need an OB expert. Ask whether the firm has worked with experts in the relevant specialty.
5. Knowledge of New Jersey Law and Courts
Medical malpractice laws vary significantly by state. You need an attorney who knows New Jersey’s specific requirements:
- The Affidavit of Merit requirement and its 60-day deadline
- New Jersey’s two-year statute of limitations and the discovery rule
- Expert witness qualification standards
- Local court rules and procedures
- The tendencies of judges in different counties
Are you admitted to practice in New Jersey?
This seems obvious, but verify. Also ask about experience in the specific county where your case would be filed.
Do you handle cases throughout New Jersey?
An attorney who regularly practices in courts across the state will understand regional variations in how cases are handled.
Questions to Ask During Your Consultation
Your initial consultation is an opportunity to evaluate the attorney. Come prepared with questions:
About Your Case
- What is your initial assessment of my case?
- What are the strengths and weaknesses you see?
- Who would be the defendants in this case?
- What type of medical expert would review my case?
- What is the likely timeline for resolution?
- What is a realistic range of compensation if we succeed?
About the Attorney and Firm
- Who would actually handle my case day-to-day?
- Will you be the attorney trying my case if it goes to trial?
- How will you keep me informed about my case?
- How quickly do you return phone calls and emails?
- How many cases are you currently handling?
About Fees and Costs
- What is your contingency fee percentage?
- Are there different percentages for settlement versus trial?
- Who pays for costs (experts, records, depositions) during the case?
- If we lose, do I owe anything for costs?
- How are costs deducted from any recovery—before or after the attorney fee?
Understanding Contingency Fees
Most medical malpractice attorneys work on contingency, meaning they receive a percentage of your recovery rather than hourly fees. This arrangement makes litigation accessible to people who couldn’t otherwise afford to pursue claims.
Typical contingency percentages in New Jersey:
- 33.33% (one-third) is common for settlements
- 40% for cases that go to trial
- Some firms charge lower percentages; some charge higher
New Jersey has rules governing contingency fees in personal injury cases. For recoveries over certain thresholds, the percentage decreases. Ask your attorney to explain their fee structure clearly.
Important: Understand how costs are handled. Costs can be substantial in medical malpractice cases. Clarify:
- Does the firm advance costs, or must you pay them?
- Are costs deducted from your share or before fees are calculated?
- If you lose, are you responsible for costs already incurred?
Red Flags to Avoid
Be wary of attorneys who:
Guarantee results. No honest attorney can guarantee outcomes in medical malpractice cases. Anyone who promises a specific recovery amount before investigating is not being truthful.
Pressure you to sign immediately. A reputable attorney will give you time to make an informed decision. High-pressure tactics suggest the attorney is more concerned with signing cases than evaluating them.
Lack specific malpractice experience. General personal injury attorneys may want the case but lack the specialized knowledge to handle it properly.
Seem too busy to talk to you. If the attorney can’t give you attention during the consultation, imagine how available they’ll be during the two to four years of litigation.
Won’t clearly explain their fee structure. Transparency about fees and costs is essential. Vague answers suggest potential problems.
Have a history of disciplinary actions. Check the New Jersey Judiciary’s website for any disciplinary history. Minor issues may be explainable, but patterns of misconduct are disqualifying.
The Importance of Personal Rapport
Beyond credentials and experience, consider whether you’re comfortable with the attorney as a person. You’ll work together closely for years, sharing difficult details of your medical experience. You want someone who:
- Listens carefully and shows genuine interest in your situation
- Explains things clearly without condescension
- Responds to your questions and concerns
- Makes you feel like a priority, not just a case number
- Treats you with respect and compassion
Trust your instincts. If something feels off during the consultation, it probably won’t improve during years of litigation.
Getting a Second Opinion
Don’t feel obligated to hire the first attorney you consult. In fact, meeting with multiple attorneys can help you:
- Compare assessments of your case’s merit
- Understand different fee structures
- Evaluate different communication styles
- Make a more informed decision
Most malpractice attorneys offer free consultations, so there’s no cost to shopping around.
The Consultation Is a Two-Way Street
Remember that the attorney is also evaluating whether to take your case. Medical malpractice attorneys invest significant time and money in cases, so they’re selective about which cases they accept.
Be honest and thorough in describing your situation. Bring relevant documents if you have them. The attorney needs complete information to assess your case fairly.
If an attorney declines your case, ask why. Sometimes there are procedural issues (statute of limitations problems) or evidentiary challenges that would apply regardless of attorney. Understanding the reasons can help you determine whether to seek other opinions.
Your Attorney as Your Advocate
The attorney-client relationship in a medical malpractice case is a partnership. Your attorney brings legal expertise, resources, and advocacy skills. You bring knowledge of what happened to you and the determination to see justice done.
Choose an attorney who treats this relationship seriously—someone who will fight for you, keep you informed, and guide you through a challenging process with competence and compassion.
The right attorney can make the difference between a case that succeeds and one that fails, between fair compensation and inadequate settlement, between an empowering experience and a frustrating one.
Take your time, ask hard questions, and choose wisely. Your future may depend on it.
—
Contact Gencarelli & Rimmassa Law Firm
At Gencarelli & Rimmassa Law Firm, we dedicate our practice to representing victims of medical malpractice throughout New Jersey. With decades of combined experience, a track record of successful verdicts and settlements, and the resources to take on the toughest cases, we provide the skilled advocacy our clients deserve.
We work on a contingency fee basis—you pay nothing unless we recover compensation for you. We limit our caseload to ensure every client receives personal attention, and we’re always available to answer your questions and address your concerns.
We invite you to see the difference experienced, dedicated representation makes. Contact Gencarelli & Rimmassa today for a free, confidential consultation. We’ll listen to your story, honestly evaluate your case, and explain how we can help.
Call (201) 549-8737 today for your free case evaluation. Let us show you what committed advocacy looks like.
