Surgery requires extraordinary precision, skill, and attention to detail. When you entrust a surgeon with your body, you place your life in their hands, expecting the highest level of care. While the vast majority of surgical procedures in New Jersey hospitals go smoothly, preventable surgical errors continue to harm thousands of patients each year.
If you or a loved one has suffered harm due to a surgical mistake in New Jersey, you deserve to understand what went wrong and what legal options may be available to you. This comprehensive guide explains the most common types of surgical errors, who may be held liable, and how New Jersey law protects patients who have been injured by preventable surgical negligence.
Understanding Surgical Errors: More Than Just Bad Outcomes
Not every surgical complication constitutes malpractice. Surgery inherently carries risks, and even the most skilled surgeons cannot guarantee perfect outcomes every time. However, there is a critical difference between an unavoidable complication and a preventable error caused by negligence.
A surgical error becomes medical malpractice when the surgeon, surgical team, or hospital fails to meet the accepted standard of care—when they make a mistake that a reasonably competent medical professional in the same specialty would not have made under similar circumstances.
The Reality of Surgical Errors
Studies suggest that surgical errors—sometimes called “never events” because they should never happen—occur with alarming frequency. According to research published in medical journals, an estimated 4,000 surgical errors occur each year in the United States, ranging from wrong-site surgery to retained surgical instruments.
In New Jersey, with its numerous hospitals and surgical centers performing thousands of procedures daily, patients must understand their rights when preventable errors cause harm.
Common Types of Surgical Errors
Surgical errors can take many forms, each with potentially devastating consequences for patients and their families.
Wrong-Site Surgery
Perhaps the most shocking type of surgical error is operating on the wrong body part. This includes:
- Wrong-side surgery: Operating on the left kidney instead of the right, the wrong knee, or the wrong eye
- Wrong-level surgery: Operating on the wrong vertebra or spinal level
- Wrong-patient surgery: Performing a procedure on a patient who was not supposed to receive it
These errors are classified as “never events” by the medical community because they are entirely preventable through proper protocols. Modern surgical safety checklists—including the widely adopted “time-out” procedure where the surgical team verifies the patient, procedure, and site before incision—should prevent these mistakes. When they occur, it typically indicates a serious breakdown in safety protocols.
Retained Surgical Objects
Leaving a surgical instrument, sponge, or other foreign object inside a patient’s body is another devastating type of surgical error. Retained objects can cause:
- Severe infection and sepsis
- Internal bleeding and organ damage
- Chronic pain and discomfort
- Additional surgeries to remove the object
- In extreme cases, death
Sponges are the most commonly retained objects because they can be difficult to see once they absorb blood. Operating rooms have strict counting protocols to prevent these errors, but fatigue, distraction, or inadequate staffing can lead to tragic mistakes.
Nerve Damage
Surgeons must carefully navigate around nerves during procedures. When nerves are accidentally cut, stretched, or compressed, patients may experience:
- Numbness or loss of sensation
- Chronic pain or burning sensations
- Weakness or paralysis
- Loss of function in affected limbs or organs
While some nerve damage is an accepted risk of certain procedures, excessive or unnecessary nerve damage caused by carelessness may constitute malpractice.
Anesthesia-Related Surgical Errors
The anesthesia team plays a critical role in surgical safety. Errors in anesthesia can include:
- Administering too much or too little anesthesia
- Failing to monitor vital signs during surgery
- Intubation errors that damage the airway
- Failure to recognize and respond to complications
- Allowing patients to wake during surgery (anesthesia awareness)
These errors can cause brain damage, heart attacks, permanent injury, or death.
Infections from Poor Sterility
Surgical site infections can occur when proper sterile techniques are not followed. Hospitals and surgical centers have strict protocols to prevent infection, including:
- Proper sterilization of surgical instruments
- Sterile draping and gowning procedures
- Pre-operative antibiotic administration when appropriate
- Post-operative wound care
When these protocols are ignored or poorly executed, patients may develop serious infections requiring additional hospitalization, antibiotic treatment, or even additional surgeries.
Performing Unnecessary Surgery
In some cases, surgical malpractice involves performing a procedure that was not medically necessary. This can occur when:
- A surgeon fails to properly diagnose the condition before operating
- Alternative, less invasive treatments were available but not considered
- Financial motivations influence the decision to operate
- The risks of surgery outweighed any potential benefits
Patients who undergo unnecessary surgery face all the risks of the procedure without any legitimate medical benefit.
Who Can Be Held Liable for Surgical Errors?
Surgical errors often involve multiple parties, and determining liability requires careful investigation of the circumstances surrounding your injury.
The Surgeon
The operating surgeon bears primary responsibility for the procedure and typically faces liability when:
- They personally made the error that caused injury
- They failed to properly supervise residents or assistants
- They proceeded with surgery despite inadequate preparation
- They failed to obtain proper informed consent
Other Surgical Team Members
Nurses, surgical technicians, and other team members may share liability if their negligence contributed to the error. For example, a surgical nurse responsible for counting sponges may be liable if a retained sponge causes harm.
Anesthesiologists
The anesthesiologist or nurse anesthetist has independent responsibility for managing anesthesia safely. They may be liable for dosage errors, monitoring failures, or delayed response to complications.
The Hospital
Under New Jersey law, hospitals can be held liable for surgical errors through several legal theories:
Respondeat Superior: The hospital may be liable for the negligent acts of its employees, including nurses and staff members.
Corporate Negligence: Hospitals have independent duties to maintain safe facilities, properly credential and supervise medical staff, and implement adequate safety protocols. A hospital that fails to meet these duties—for example, by allowing an understaffed surgical team or failing to maintain equipment—may be directly liable.
Apparent Agency: Even when surgeons are technically independent contractors rather than employees, the hospital may be liable if patients reasonably believed the surgeon was a hospital employee.
The Impact of Surgical Errors
Surgical errors can have life-altering consequences that extend far beyond the immediate physical injury.
Physical Consequences
Depending on the type of error, victims may face:
- Additional surgeries to correct the mistake
- Permanent disability or disfigurement
- Chronic pain requiring long-term management
- Reduced life expectancy
- Complete loss of function in affected body parts
Financial Burden
The financial impact of surgical errors can be staggering:
- Extensive additional medical treatment
- Rehabilitation and physical therapy
- Lost wages during extended recovery
- Inability to return to previous employment
- Costs of long-term care or assistance
Emotional and Psychological Trauma
Beyond physical harm, surgical error victims often experience:
- Depression and anxiety
- Post-traumatic stress disorder
- Loss of trust in medical providers
- Strain on family relationships
- Reduced quality of life
Proving Surgical Malpractice in New Jersey
To succeed with a surgical malpractice claim in New Jersey, you must establish four essential elements.
Duty of Care
You must show that a doctor-patient relationship existed and the healthcare providers owed you a duty of care. In surgical cases, this is typically straightforward once you’ve been scheduled for and undergone a procedure.
Breach of Standard of Care
You must prove that the surgeon or surgical team failed to meet the applicable standard of care. Expert testimony from a qualified surgeon in the same specialty is essential to establish what a competent surgeon would have done and how the defendant’s actions fell short.
Causation
You must demonstrate that the breach of care directly caused your injury. This can be complex in surgical cases because some complications occur even with excellent care. Your attorney and medical experts must establish that your specific injury was caused by negligence, not by the inherent risks of the procedure.
Damages
You must prove that you suffered actual harm—physical, financial, or emotional—as a result of the surgical error.
The Affidavit of Merit Requirement
New Jersey law requires that within 60 days of the defendant filing an answer to your complaint, you must submit an Affidavit of Merit from a qualified medical expert. This expert must confirm that there is a reasonable basis to believe that malpractice occurred. Failing to meet this requirement can result in dismissal of your case.
The Statute of Limitations for Surgical Error Claims
In New Jersey, you generally have two years from the date of the surgical error—or from when you discovered or reasonably should have discovered the injury—to file a malpractice lawsuit. However, this timeline can be complex:
- Retained surgical objects may not be discovered for months or years
- Some injuries develop gradually after surgery
- The discovery rule may extend your deadline if the injury was not immediately apparent
Because time limits are strict and the investigation process takes time, consulting an attorney as soon as you suspect a surgical error is critical.
What to Do If You’ve Been Harmed by a Surgical Error
If you believe you’ve been injured by a surgical mistake in New Jersey, take these important steps:
1. Get the Medical Care You Need: Your health is the priority. Seek appropriate treatment for any complications or injuries.
2. Obtain Your Complete Medical Records: Request copies of all records related to your surgery, including operative reports, anesthesia records, nursing notes, and any imaging studies.
3. Document Your Experience: Keep detailed notes about your symptoms, treatments, how the injury has affected your daily life, and any communications with healthcare providers.
4. Preserve Evidence: Do not dispose of any documents, medical devices, or other potential evidence related to your case.
5. Consult an Experienced Medical Malpractice Attorney: Surgical malpractice cases are complex and require substantial resources to investigate and prosecute. An experienced attorney can help you understand whether you have a viable claim.
Seeking Justice After a Surgical Error
Surgical errors can be devastating, but they don’t have to define your future. New Jersey law provides a path to hold negligent surgeons, hospitals, and other healthcare providers accountable for preventable mistakes.
Pursuing a surgical malpractice claim not only helps you recover compensation for your losses—medical expenses, lost income, pain and suffering, and reduced quality of life—but also helps protect future patients by encouraging higher standards of care.
If a surgical error has turned your life upside down, you don’t have to face this challenge alone. Understanding your rights is the first step toward recovery and justice.
—
Contact Gencarelli & Rimmassa Law Firm
If you or a loved one has been injured by a surgical error in New Jersey, the experienced attorneys at Gencarelli & Rimmassa Law Firm are ready to fight for you. We understand the physical, emotional, and financial devastation that surgical malpractice causes, and we have the resources and expertise to take on hospitals and insurance companies.
Our team works on a contingency fee basis—you pay nothing unless we win your case. We have access to top medical experts who can evaluate your case and provide the testimony needed to prove your claim.
Time is limited under New Jersey law. Don’t wait to explore your legal options. Contact Gencarelli & Rimmassa today for a free, confidential consultation.
Call (201) 549-8737 now for your free case evaluation. Let us help you get the justice and compensation you deserve.
